leidenlawblog

The Tata saga: Another environmental issue on the court's plate?

The Tata saga: Another environmental issue on the court's plate?

After local residents filed charges against Tata Steel, last February the Dutch Public Prosecution Service (PPS) started criminal investigations into the steel company. These events fit in a broader trend of citizens turning to the judiciary when they feel other institutions are failing them.

The charges filed by Bénédicte Ficq on behalf of many hundreds of local residents and a number of interest organisations concern a violation of Article 173a of the Dutch Criminal Code: intentionally and unlawfully emitting a substance into the soil, air, or surface waters, thereby endangering public health or the life of another person (under 1) or endangering another person’s life and causing someone’s death (under 2). The investigations the PPS announced at the beginning of February 2022 in response to these charges are not the only criminal proceedings against the company. At the time of the announcement, Tata Steel was already being investigated for alleged violations of its environmental permit, as the dust released during the steel production spreads further from the company’s premises than the permitted two metres. The PPS had already announced earlier that they would be prosecuting Tata Steel for these charges. In addition, several orders subject to periodic penalty payment (lasten onder dwangsom) have been imposed in recent years, which the company has challenged time and again. None of these interventions seem to have substantially changed the situation.[1]

At the same time, research shows that there are relatively many health complaints in the vicinity of Tata Steel and that the air quality in the company’s surroundings is structurally worse than in the rest of the Netherlands. The graphite rains that occurred in the company’s vicinity, which produced large clouds of dust containing heavy metals, caused concern among many local residents as well. And another recent study by the National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM) shows that the amounts of lead in the vicinity of the factory in particular can be harmful to playing children.

Studies on the health of people living in the company’s vicinity are not something new. Such research has been conducted for more than 25 years. An overview of relevant research is available on the RIVM webpage on Tata Steel. At the time of writing this blog, no fewer than 31 reports can be found about public health in the region where the company is located. The oldest report available there (from 1995) already stated that the steel industry appeared to contribute significantly to concentrations of particulates and that these, in turn, were associated with a statistically significant decrease in lung capacity. According to an overview document that lists the various studies and which can be found on the website of the province of Noord-Holland, Tata Steel's emissions have a negative impact on the living environment, although there is still uncertainty about the exact cause and degree of health risks.

In view of the many years of controversy surrounding the steel manufacturer, one may wonder why action has not been taken sooner and more vigorously, for example at a political level. In line with this, last year the Randstad Court of Audit recommended a greater regulatory role for the national government. On the other hand, it has been pointed out that political intervention is difficult in practice, both on a national and on a local level. Tata Steel is one of the most frequently inspected companies in the Netherlands and the company has been said to generally adhere to the standards. Moreover, the relevant standards are often drawn up at EU level – that is why, according to the responsible State Secretary at the time (Van Weyenberg), stricter European standards were needed. It has been said that the environmental service organisation (omgevingsdienst) and the provincial authorities would like to impose stricter standards on Tata Steel, but that standards simply cannot be interpreted more strictly for one European company than for another.

Nevertheless, the perceived lack of (effective and expeditious) interventions by political, administrative and legal authorities does seem to be an important reason for the recent developments surrounding Tata Steel. For example, the village council of Wijk aan Zee, in a response to the announced prosecution of the company for violating its permit, indicated that in this case one ‘cannot rely on the political authorities when it really matters’ and that according to them the enforcement of the permit was inadequate due to the environmental service organisation being structurally understaffed. And Bénédicte Ficq, when providing explanations about the charges she had filed on behalf of local residents and interest organisations, pointed to the slow progress of the ongoing criminal investigations. According to her, the authorities have been ‘waiting long and working in a fragmented way’ and ‘way too little is being done to tackle the effects of air pollution caused by Tata, often in violation of the rules’.

Taken together, we see a conflict between Tata Steel, on the one hand, and local residents and interest organisations, on the other hand. It concerns suspected violations and harmful health effects of the company's emissions, difficulties in intervening at political and administrative levels, and citizens taking matters into their own hands by trying to bring the case to a criminal court. Interestingly, these events seem to fit within a broader development in which citizens or interest organisations take social problems to the judiciary when they believe that other institutions are lagging behind. Dutch examples in the field of climate change and environmental pollution outside the field of criminal law are the Urgenda and Shell cases and the Council of State’s rulings on nitrogen. We also see a similar development with regard to other themes – for example, the case against the tobacco industry (also initiated by Ficq) and cases in which measures against COVID are being challenged.

Like these other cases, recent developments in the Tata Steel case raise the question of which processes exactly cause citizens to try to bring these kinds of politically sensitive cases involving underlying social problems to court. The fact that this seems to be happening more and more nowadays, and the normative questions that may arise in some cases about the role of the courts, make it all the more relevant to properly understand these processes. This is one of the themes that is being investigated from different points of view within the Institutions for Conflict Resolution research group. This summer’s conference on Courts as an Arena for Societal Change may already provide some answers.

More than 120 scholars from all over the world will share their findings and views on 8 and 9 July 2022 at Leiden Law School during the conference Courts as an Arena for Societal Change. Several blogs will be published on the Leiden Law Blog on the themes of the conference.

[1] Essens, O.D. (2021). Naar een effectieve handhaving op maat in het omgevingsrecht. Tijdschrift voor Omgevingsrecht, 2021/3, 95-106.

7 Comments

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

Hello! Can we take a moment to recognize the awesomeness of this site? I'm a personal injury attorney, and let me reveal you, discovering a site that delivers helpful insights without overwhelming you in legalese is a gem. So, why the beam on my face? I've recently introduced my own digital oasis visit it , a space where injury law crosses paths with real-world conversations. From getting the legal nitty-gritty to exposing myths, my platform is here to empower you with knowledge. No sophisticated language, just simple discussions about your rights and how to handle personal injury situations like a pro. Ready to plunge? Come with me on this adventure of legal clarity.Hey chums Can we talk about the gem that is this platform? I'm a personal injury attorney, and let me reveal the details – online spaces like these are my favorite zone. Now, why the excitement? Alright, I just revealed my own virtual hub , and I couldn't be more elated to share it with you. Imagine a space where personal injury law isn't laden with complicated terminology but presented in routine speech. That's what my site is all about. platform is all about. Traversing the planet in personal injury could be like tiptoeing through a maze, and my goal is to be your guide, your pal in the legal realm. From unpacking the responsibility of medical records to discussing the sentimental journey of a personalized injury, my own site Addresses it all. No, you will not uncover highfalutin legal terms here – just genuine talk regarding the entitlements, legal process, and tactics and to manage life's uncertainties hurls your way. Hence, for what purpose should you visit? Well, my buddies, it's a zone where you can get a virtual coffee, unwind, and disentangle the difficulties pertaining to individual injury law without having the stress. Whether you're dealing with a slip and fall or reflecting on a personal injury claim, my platform is your chosen source for helpful advice, insights, and the hint of juridical authorization.
[url=https://amicuslegalgroup.com/practice-areas/dui-defense/multiple-dui-offenses/][color=black_url]Legal assistance for individuals dealing with truck collision incidents[/color][/url]
[url=http://play4.games/threads/guidance-on-deal-with-insurers-in-the-aftermath-of-a-injury-accident.393063/]Guidance on Deal with Insurers In the aftermath of a Injury Accident[/url] 02fb2_9

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

Hey everyone! Just came across this precious discovery of a platform and had to share the happiness. As a personal injury legal counsel, uncovering a spot filled with helpful knowledge is like hitting the jackpot. Elated to disclose my very own site , where personal injury law meets down-to-earth discussions. Explore for a new perspective on your rights and navigating the legal labyrinth. Cheers to the discovery and judicial empowerment.
[url=https://amicuslegalgroup.com/2020/07/30/another-vehicle-ran-a-stop-sign-and-hit-me-la-car-accident-lawyer/][color=black_url]Legal assistance for victims of truck incidents[/color][/url]
[url=https://pyro-ua.com/forum/showthread.php?p=7308#post7308]Looking for Compensation for Emotional Distress in Injury Cases[/url] b7_a015

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

How's it going! Can we take a second to acknowledge the greatness of this platform? I'm a personal injury lawyer, and let me tell you, discovering a platform that delivers hands-on insights without submerging you in legalese is a treasure. So, why the smirk on my face? I've recently revealed my own online oasis check it out , a spot in which injury legal collides with practical conversations. From comprehending the legal nitty-gritty to unmasking myths, my platform is here to empower you with awareness. No sophisticated language, just direct discussions about your rights and how to handle personal injury situations like a pro. Ready to dive in? Join me on this exploration of legal clarity.Hey acquaintances Can we chat about the gem that is this platform? I'm a personal injury legal counsel, and let me disclose the information – sites like these are my joyful spot. Now, why the excitement? Okay, I've lately unveiled my own virtual hub , and I couldn't be more thrilled to share it with you. Picture a place where personal injury law isn't draped in complicated terminology nevertheless presented in everyday speech. That's what my website is all about. site is all about. Guiding the world in personal harm could be like moving gingerly through a maze, and my goal is to be your companion, your friend in the legal realm. From unpacking the responsibility of medical records to conversing on The sentimental journey connected to an personalized harm, my site Covers everything. Not at all, you won't find highfalutin legal terms here – just real discuss about the rights, the procedure, and methods and to tackle life's challenges throws your way. Hence, why should you check it out? Well, my friends, it's a space where you can grab a virtual coffee, relax, and decipher those complications regarding private damage legislation minus that anxieties. Whether you're coping with a slip and fall or considering a personal injury claim, my website is your chosen source for practical recommendation, views, and an touch related to legal enablement.
[url=https://amicuslegalgroup.com/2020/11/20/seeking-medical-help-after-an-accident/][color=black_url]Legal services for individuals dealing with truck collision cases[/color][/url]
[url=https://chatsuk.com/threads/the-function-of-physical-and-emotional-distress-in-personal-injury-reparation.605374/]The Function of Physical and Emotional Distress in Personal Injury Reparation[/url] 02fb6_5

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

Hey everyone! Ecstatic I stumbled upon this awesome website! As a personal injury lawyer, plainness in legal talks is totally my vibe. Elated to inform you about my platform , a space where we decode personal injury law without the bother. Explore, join the conversation, and let's sail through the official journey together.
https://amicuslegalgroup.com/2022-breaking-the-stigma-scholarship-terms-and-conditions/
[url=https://vmhomemart.com/product/gojeeva-sconce-wall-lamp/]Methods to Deal with Insurers After a Personal Injury Crash[/url] 33a5199

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

Thankful for sites like this one that foster learning. Check out my hub, and let's navigate the maze together! site to spread professional insights. Believe me, grasping the subtleties of personal injury cases can transform your awareness. Grateful of platforms, just like this treasure, that encourage spreading wisdom. Check out my hub, and let's journey through the labyrinth together!
https://amicuslegalgroup.com/2020/03/02/commercial-trucking-accidents/
[url=https://www.transe-hypnose.com/sujet/traumatic-brain-injuries-and-longterm-consequences-and-legal-solutions.12352/]Traumatic Brain Injuries and LongTerm Consequences and Legal Solutions[/url] 6eca5c8

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

Hey confidants! Can we snatch a second to appreciate the goldmine that is this site? As a personal injury attorney, discovering platforms that break down legal challenges for real folks is like uncovering an needle in the hay. On that note, I've recently compiled an individual project. hub regarding anything injury cases. It is nonetheless not your usual lawful center no fancy jargon, just down-to-earth discussions concerning one's rights, that legal nitty-gritty, and how to handle difficult circumstances. I think in creating legal info reachable for everyone, thus plunge into my site, discover, and let's start this legal journey alongside.
<a href=https://amicuslegalgroup.com/areas-served/banning-personal-injury-lawyer/><font color=black_url>Encouraging legal support for individuals dealing with collision incidents</font></a>
<a href=https://ourpoliticalhammer.com/mybb/showthread.php?tid=77728>Assessing LongTerm Care Expenses Following a Serious Injury</a> 99d7498

Charlesneeks CharlesneeksTR

The fact is that a person implicated of a crime will probably get a sore offer, minus the options of a competent attorney. Therefore, if you or a relative happens to be accused of committing a criminal activity, do not hesitate to make contact with certainly one of our Los Angeles county criminal defense lawyer gurus. Our team Our firm simply fill every rank and file aided by the recommended professional minds in the neighborhood. All of us of judiciary specialists are particularly proficient in what the law states and also the red tape that complicates a amount of criminal arrest scenarios. Our criminal defense legal professionals are true gurus. These legal representatives should never pass personal judgment on a client faced with heinous criminal activity such as for instance murder, rape and even child molestation. They need to and to the best of their capability defend a customer that they might individually think to be guilty regarding the crime in which they've been charged. Once more, they need to put away individual values then sentiments and defend a customer that has been charged with committing ineffable actions. Which means, coming to be a criminal defense legal representative not only usually takes effort and true character to defending every single man or woman's privileges granted underneath the law. Every circumstances offers its very own particular groups of obstacles regardless of which region of the court room any client is found. To every type of law you will find advantages and disadvantages, however with criminal law some appear to simply look at cons. There is always the chance of a inappropriate conviction, a mistrial as part of a remarkably essential case, and the dangers of working with intense criminal, especially their profession and various criminal types of large pay. Many practitioners can easily agree totally that there clearly was a long range of cons, and negative comments that go along with the occupation, but the majority prospering attorneys be seemingly in a position to see beyond the rough words and steps, and are usually able to begin to see the good that comes out of doing criminal law. The fantastic verdicts just that additionally show your potential clients sinlessness to your locality, all of the the cases and clients, together with capacity to be cross investigating witnesses into the court room almost every holiday, usually are thought about. if you'd like to see more about this specific topic come visit my favorite martial art web-site: https://amicuslegalgroup.com/2020/06/06/common-spinal-cord-injuries-sci-in-a-california-bicycle-accident/[color=#000_url - debt settlement vs bankruptcy round Jurupa Valley CA

Add a comment