Who controls the farm’s data? Farmers’ data, farmers’ rights
Soil sensors, satellite data and farm apps are reshaping how food is grown. But who controls that data – and who protects the farmers who produce it?
The digitalisation of food systems has opened a new frontier of data extraction. From mobile phone-based advisory services to high-tech tractors, data has become central to how food is produced, with far-reaching consequences for the people who produce it.
Corporations, governments and international organisations hail digital technologies as a cure for the problems of today’s food systems. Although these claims are highly disputed, digitalisation is already reshaping peasant livelihoods – with minimal legal regulation and oversight. A rights-centred approach is urgently needed to protect the autonomy and needs of small-scale producers who grow a significant portion of the world’s food.
Agriculture as the latest frontier of data extraction
Food systems have always been a site of innovation and experimentation. For millennia, farmers have developed their own seeds and farming practices. The ‘Green Revolution’ from the 1950s onwards changed that. It imposed industrial technologies such as high-yield varieties, chemical inputs, and mechanisation on food systems across the world. The result was stark inequality, environmental damage, and corporate concentration – issues that still afflict many agricultural systems today.
The recent push for digital agriculture risks repeating that history. Digital tools are promoted as a solution to climate change, biodiversity decline, and food security, but there is little evidence that they will deliver on these promises. Yet, they are already transforming rural life and shifting power relations.
Researchers have identified a long list of risks: government surveillance of peasants, corporate concentration and technological lock-ins, digitally-enabled biopiracy and the environmental footprint of digital infrastructure. That raises a crucial question: is the law equipped to deal with these risks?
Who controls agricultural data?
Digital agricultural technologies are incredibly diverse, but they all run on data: about land, soil, crops, livestock, markets, weather, biodiversity and even genetic resources. These data feed scientific repositories, government registries, and proprietary platforms.
In a recent report, written as part of the ERC-funded DigiFood project, we examine who controls this data, and with what consequences. Our main finding is that conventional legal approaches often fail to address the specific challenges of agricultural data.
A fragmented landscape
Take data protection law. Agricultural data is often qualified as non-personal data, which places it outside the scope of the rigid rules that apply to personal data. But once information on land and crop production are combined, individual farmers can easily be identified. More fundamentally, privacy law is built around the individual, whereas many peasant and Indigenous communities hold land and knowledge collectively.
Efforts to strengthen the governance of agricultural data are under way, but the regulatory landscape remains fragmented. One of the biggest problems is that there is neither agreement on what ‘data governance’ means, nor on the value of agricultural data. We identify three competing paradigms: techno-economic, socio-political and environmental. Each approach has its own objectives, values and institutional arenas. The techno-economic one revolves around data interoperability, socio-political governance seeks to distributional questions, and environmental governance centres on the ecological role of this data.
Yet, all three paradigms treat agricultural data first and foremost as commercial assets. Questions of equity and justice are left to private, voluntary initiatives.
Towards a human rights approach
To put peasant and Indigenous communities back at the centre of agricultural data governance, we argue for a human rights-based approach. But what would that approach look like in practice?
That question was at the heart of a workshop on Human Rights and the Digitalization of Food Systems, held at the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) in Rome in October. It was organised by the DigiFood team together with the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food and the UN Working Group on the Rights of Peasants, and brought together researchers, activists, and policy experts from a wide range of contexts.
Case studies showed how varied the problems raised by agricultural data governance are. However, they also demonstrated how reframing agricultural data through the right to food and the UN Declaration on the Rights of Peasants (UNDROP) could put food producers at the centre over decisions about how their data is managed as well as how digital technologies are designed and deployed. Moreover, they offer important protections for the diverse knowledge systems that are that are critical for repairing and regenerating global food systems.
These insights from Rome will feed into the Special Rapporteur’s upcoming thematic report. Just as importantly, they are the opening a new frontier of the global digital rights movement, bringing together the small-scale food producers who feed the world, with urban, environmental and labour movements to revitalise human rights for the digital era.
0 Comments
Add a comment