Insolvency for Perry Sport: still room for the interests of unsecured creditors?
The recent insolvency for Perry Sport shows the advantageous position of banks in current insolvencies. One of the causes is the development of the collective deed of pledge, as accepted in Dix q.q./ING. How much room is left for the unsecured creditors?
On 23 February 2016 the sports chain stores Perry Sport and Aktiesport were declared insolvent. Only a few days later the appointed liquidator confirmed to the Dutch newspaper NRC that he had initiated a law suit against the four banks of the insolvent company. His reason being the current tendency in insolvencies: that the banks are first in line to claim their almost all-embracing security rights, giving the liquidator no other role than to sit by and watch how the insolvent company’s assets disappear. Even though in this case a settlement was eventually agreed upon, a similar case was observed previously in the Dutch Supreme Court judgment Dix q.q./ING (2012), in which the Court confirmed the advantageous position that banks hold.
Dix q.q./ING (2012)
ING Bank supplied a loan to a company and in return it created a package of security rights on the assets of the company. In addition, the company authorised the bank to pledge all its existing and future receivables. In endorsing this power of attorney the bank frequently used a so-called collective deed of pledge, a document in which both the receivables to be pledged and the pledgors were described in a general way. Unfortunately the company went into insolvency and the liquidator (Dix) was facing an almost empty insolvent estate, because most of the assets had been securitised by the bank.
Legal questions
In this judgment the Supreme Court looked at three questions. The first was whether the power of attorney had been agreed validly. The Supreme Court decided that this was indeed the case. There were no signs of any unlawful conflict of interest. The second question was whether the receivables referred to in the collective deed of pledge were described in a sufficiently precise manner. Lastly the Supreme Court had to decide whether all future receivables up to the day the company was declared insolvent had been lawfully pledged.
Requirement of specificity
According to Dutch law (sections 84(2) and 98, Book 3 Dutch Civil Code (DCC)), receivables have to be described in a sufficiently precise manner in order to be lawfully pledged. In earlier judgments the Dutch Supreme Court had decided that receivables themselves were allowed to be described generically in a deed of pledge by using a so-called ‘catch-all clause’. In line with this, the Supreme Court decided in the current case that the pledgors could also be described generically in the deed of pledge for the receivables to be described sufficiently precisely according to Dutch law. Therefore, the second question was answered affirmatively as well.
All future receivables?
Section 239(1), Book 3 DCC stipulates that only receivables that existed when the pledge was established or receivables that will result from a juridical relationship already existing at that moment can be pledged. Receivables that will result from a juridical relationship that is yet to exist, can therefore not be pledged in advance - for example, future rent that will be due on the grounds of lease agreements that a landlord will enter into in the future. By creating this limitation, the legislature presumably envisaged some protection for unsecured creditors, since the unpledged receivables would be available for recourse in the event of the insolvency of the debtor. The almost daily registration of collective deeds of pledge overcomes this. The Dutch Supreme Court keeps to the text of this section: the legal relationship has to exist when the pledge is established, i.e. when the collective deed of pledge is registered. Daily registration therefore means that receivables that cannot be pledged when the loan is given will still be lawfully pledged, circumventing the legal obstruction: whenever new receivables are created, these are covered by the collective deed of pledge.
Concluding remarks
All future movable assets could already be pledged in advance. Following Dix q.q. v. ING, the same is actually true for all future receivables. Up till then it was required to periodically register extensive lists of receivables to be pledged. Now, a concise collective deed of pledge suffices due to the extension of the requirement of specificity. This makes the security right more similar to the English floating charge. The Supreme Court has in effect created a generic security right, entailing that the statutory limitation from section 239(1), Book 3 DCC has lost its meaning. The Supreme Court is well aware of this, but is unable to step in, since Dutch judges are not allowed to make the necessary legal-political choices. In its annual report for 2012, the Supreme Court therefore suggests that the legislature at least considers the current position of unsecured creditors. We encourage the legislature to take into account developments in England: in 2003, the English legislature added section 176A to the Insolvency Act 1986, providing unsecured creditors with the prescribed part, a share of the realised assets that would otherwise be owed to the floating charge holder. We consider it worth investigating the incorporation of such a provision into Dutch law since this would bring the equality of creditors disadvantaged by Dix q.q. v. ING one step closer. Or is the willingness of secured creditors to provide credit deemed more important than unsecured creditors’ willingness to trade?
This contribution originated as an assignment of the master’s course Privatissimum Civil law, under the supervision of mr. Jeroen van der Weide. In this course, students were asked to write a blog text about the Dutch Supreme Court judgment Dix q.q./ING. The best blog would be published on the Leiden Law Blog. Both authors’ blogs were selected as the ‘winning blogs’. Therefore, the authors were invited to combine their blogs and publish the final blog on the Leiden Law Blog. Both authors sincerely thank mr. Jeroen van der Weide for his valuable feedback on previous versions of this blog.
5 Comments
Finding your way about the the Social Security Disability application procedures may be an intimidating task for some. The procedure can be detailed and frustrating, as well as the odds of getting rejected are raised. This is when a social security disability legal professional is available in. Legal counsel will allow you to navigate the applying process, boost your likelihood of becoming approved, and appeal a denied claim. In this specific article, we're going to mention at least five subject areas linked to the purpose of a social security disability solicitor.
Navigating the Social Security Disability application system by using a lawyer
The social security disability application processes may be confusing then stressful. Legal counsel makes it possible to understand the requirements and make suggestions through the procedure. They can also assist you to gather the mandatory professional medical facts and certification to guide ones claim. They are able to further help in arranging someone for the hearing, if necessary.
The necessity of healthcare evidence in a Social Security Disability claim
Medical evidence is vital in a social security disability case. It is utilized to prove which you posses a medical condition that prevents you against performing. Legal counsel makes it possible to accumulate the mandatory medical information and introduce it in a manner that is most probably to be acknowledged because of the social security organisation. They could also allow you to obtain medical records along with other records that maintain your claim.
Common myths more than Social Security Disability and just how an attorney will help
There are numerous myths up to social security disability. For example, many people think that only those people who are permanently disabled are qualified to receive benefits. However, it is not true. A lawyer makes it possible to understand the eligibility requirements and dispel any misconceptions you could have. They can also provide help with simple tips to present your case when you look at the most favorable light.
The appeals process for waived Social Security Disability cases and how an attorney can help
Should your claim is denied, you have the straight to appeal. A legal professional will allow you to comprehend the appeals strategy and portray you throughout the hearing. They could also assist you to gather additional evidence and create a stronger case to improve your chances of winning.
How to choose the best Social Security Disability lawyer or attorney for your case
You should choose a legal professional who may have valuable experience managing social security disability cases. Seek out a lawyer that is knowledgeable about the social security administration's procedures and methods. Its also wise to feel comfortable chatting with them and trust their judgment. Try to find a lawyer who can offer clear and genuine responses to your questions and provide direction for the duration of the method.
In closing, a social security disability attorney can play a vital role within the application and appeals process. They can help you go through the procedure, enhance your likelihood of getting approved, and appeal a refused claim. A lawyer will help you recognize the qualification specifications and run off any beliefs you might have. It's important to choose an attorney who's got experience maneuvering social security disability cases, sufficient reason for whom you feel safe communicating.
if you'd like to discover more about this one matter come visit your ssa attorney web-property:
[url=https://jonsipes.com/practice-areas/age-50-and-disability/][color=#000_url]local social security disability attorneys in Santa Fe New Mexico[/color][/url]
Steering through todays Social Security Disability application process can be an intimidating task for some. The method may be elaborate and time consuming, plus the likelihood of getting denied are increased. That's where a social security disability lawyer is available in. A legal professional can help you navigate the applying process, raise your likelihood of becoming accepted, then appeal a denied claim. In this specific article, we are going to mention 10 issues pertaining to the duty of a social security disability attorney.
Finding your way with regards to the the Social Security Disability application processes by using a lawyer
The social security disability application process can be confusing and also complicated. Legal counsel makes it possible to comprehend the requirements and make suggestions through the procedure. They are able to also assist you to gather the necessary professional medical facts and proof to guide ones demand. They could also help in readying someone for the proceeding, if required.
The significance of medical related evidence in a Social Security Disability claim
Medical evidence is essential in a social security disability case. It really is used to show that you maintain a medical condition that prevents you against working. A lawyer will allow you to find the required medical information and provide it in a fashion that is probably to be taken because of the social security organisation. They may be able also assist you to obtain medical records as well as other paperwork that support your case.
Prevalent misunderstandings about Social Security Disability and just how a legal professional might help
There are numerous false beliefs concerning social security disability. As an example, many individuals think that only those people who are permanently disabled are qualified to receive benefits. Though, this is simply not true. An attorney will allow you to comprehend the eligibility requirements and dispel any misconceptions you might have. They could also provide help with how exactly to present your case when you look at the most favorable light.
The appeals strategy for refused Social Security Disability scenarios and exactly how a legal professional will help
If the claim is denied, you've got the directly to appeal. A legal professional makes it possible to comprehend the appeals strategy and represent you through the hearing. They could also assist you to gather additional evidence and create a stronger case to improve your chances of triumph.
How to pick just the right Social Security Disability personal injury attorney for the case
It is vital to choose a legal professional that has practical experience dealing with social security disability matters. Search for legal counsel that is knowledgeable about the social security administration's procedures and operations. It's also wise to feel comfortable chatting with them and trust their judgment. Try to find a lawyer who can create evident and honest solutions to your questions and supply direction all through the process.
In closing, a social security disability personal injury attorney can play a crucial role within the application and appeals process. They could help you navigate the method, boost your odds of getting approved, and appeal a refuted claim. A lawyer will also help you realize the qualifications requirements and drive off any wrong ideas you've probably. It is important to choose legal counsel that has experience dealing with social security disability situations, along with that you feel at ease communicating.
If you wish to learn about more info on this one subject take a look at a Social Security Disability lawyer webpage:
[url=https://jonsipes.com/disclaimer/ ][color=#000_url]social security overpayment lawyers near me in Albuquerque NM[/color][/url]
Navigating the Social Security Disability application steps could be a daunting task for some. The procedure may be detailed and frustrating, additionally the likelihood of getting declined are significant. That's where a social security disability lawyer or attorney comes in. Legal counsel makes it possible to navigate the program process, boost your odds of getting approved, as well as appeal a denied claim. In this specific article, we shall mention 10 tips linked to the duty of a social security disability legal professional.
Steering through the Social Security Disability application process with the aid of an attorney
The social security disability application procedure could be perplexing additionally stressful. Legal counsel will allow you to comprehend the requirements and make suggestions through the procedure. They are able to also allow you to gather the mandatory health-related evidence and certification to aid your demand. They are able to further help in organizing someone for the proceeding, if necessary.
The significance of medical-related data in a Social Security Disability claim
Medical evidence is vital in a social security disability case. It really is used to show which you have got a medical condition that prevents you from performing. A lawyer can help you collect the mandatory medical proof and introduce it in a manner that is most probably to be established by the social security governing administration. They are able to also allow you to obtain medical records along with other papers that maintain your claim.
Frequent mistaken beliefs concerning Social Security Disability and just how legal counsel will help
There are lots of wrong ideas regarding social security disability. As an example, lots of people think that only those people who are permanently disabled are eligible for benefits. Nevertheless, it is not true. A lawyer will allow you to comprehend the eligibility requirements and dispel any misconceptions you have. They could also provide help with how exactly to present your case in the most favorable light.
The appeals undertaking for refused Social Security Disability cases and just how an attorney will help
In the event your claim is denied, you've got the straight to appeal. A lawyer can help you comprehend the appeals procedure and represent you throughout the hearing. They are able to also assist you to gather additional evidence and establish a stronger case to improve your odds of triumph.
How to pick the best Social Security Disability attorney at law for the case
It is vital to choose a legal professional who has got practical knowledge approaching social security disability matters. Seek out legal counsel that is acquainted with the social security administration's procedures and operations. It's also wise to feel comfortable communicating with them and trust their judgment. Seek out a legal professional who is able to provide evident and genuine responses to your questions and supply direction all through the method.
To conclude, a social security disability lawyer can play a vital role when you look at the application and appeals process. They could assist you to navigate the procedure, raise your chances of getting authorized, and appeal a declined claim. A legal professional will also help you understand the eligibility specifications and drive out any beliefs you have. It is vital to choose a legal professional who may have experience approaching social security disability cases, sufficient reason for that you feel at ease communicating.
Should you want to learn about more about your subject take a look at the S.S.A. lawyer firm website online:
[url=https://jonsipes.com/practice-areas/disability-appeals/][color=#000_url]sokolove law unum in Santa Fe NM[/color][/url]
Nice article.http://idis.uonbi. ac.ke
Congratulations, Ruben! It seems a problem that the Hoog Raad is in favor of secured credtors at present, especially on account of the lack of a filing system in Netherlands. Besides, we can see that in the USA there was a fierce debate about the efficiency and fiarness of security rights. Some writters believe that they are ineffiecient and unfair: a security right is deemed as a device of extracting a subsidy from unsecured creditors, especailly involuntory creditors (tort victims). This is an important reason why English law prescribes a released part from the floating charge.
Add a comment